JANUARY SALE Subscribe for just £5 today CLICK HERE

Apple pie or apple crumble? What do you prefer?

PUBLISHED: 17:34 13 November 2015 | UPDATED: 17:43 02 March 2018

Apple Pie or Apple Crumble - what do you prefer?

Apple Pie or Apple Crumble - what do you prefer?


Is it fair to ask anyone who loves puddings to choose between apple pie and apple crumble? Esther Leach asks award-winning chef Stephanie Moon

There must have been a light-hearted kitchen argument or two over which to serve, apple pie or apple crumble. Personally, in these days of fancy trio desserts, I don’t see why we shouldn’t have both on a plate, with custard or ice cream on the side – just another one of my greedy ideas. And while I haven’t totally dismissed the thought, I turned to Steph Moon, consultant chef at Rudding Park, Harrogate for her view on this very pressing matter.

‘At home I have two Cavalier King Charles Spaniels, Honey and Pickle and I couldn’t pick a favourite so please don’t ask me to do this,’ said Steph. That’s not helpful, I said. ‘A crispy pastry meets melting apples in a parcel verses bubbling apples covered with a crumbly, buttery blanket – how could you pick?’ argued Steph. Instead she offered these recipes to help us make up our minds. Do you have a favourite and why? We’d love to hear from you.

Email feedback@yorkshirelife.co.uk 


Apple pie is servedApple pie is served


This recipe makes two delicious pies



620g plain flour

290g unsalted butter (diced)

40g caster sugar

250ml cold water

20g ground almonds

2 whole eggs beaten


500g (net weight) peeled, diced apples

50g ground almonds

15g plain flour

30g caster sugar

Zest of one lemon

Notes: You can use baking or eating apples, depending on your preference. Bramley apples are brilliant but other apples are good too! You may need more than 500g of apples as the net weight is the final weight once peeled and diced.


For the pastry:

Place the flour and butter in a bowl and lightly crumble together until it reaches a sandy, grain like consistency. Add caster sugar and ground almonds and mix in with the butter and flour. Add the beaten eggs and mix. Slowly pour in the water whilst mixing so the pastry binds together in a ball (you may have some liquid left over).

Rest in the fridge for 15 minutes whilst you tidy down and get a rolling pin. Place a light dusting of flour on the bench.

Divide the pastry in two (there is enough for two pies). Then split the pastry again, 2/3 for the base and 1/3 for the lid. Grease your pie dish with butter and lightly dust with flour, tapping off any excess flour. Roll out the pastry base and place into your greased and floured pie dish. Repeat this process to make another pie.

For the filling:

Mix the apple in a bowl with the flour, almonds, sugar and lemon zest. Then, egg wash the side of the pastry. Place the filling into the lined pie dish until it domes over. Place the lid on top and cut off any excess pastry around the pie. Crimp the pastry using your two fore fingers and thumbs. Egg wash the lid, then sprinkle a little sugar on top. Bake in the oven at 180 degrees for 30-40minutes until cooked.

Remove, slice, dive in and enjoy!

Apple crumble is servedApple crumble is served




Crumble topping

25g oats

300g plain flour

150g unsalted butter (diced)

50g golden caster sugar

30g of whatever you fancy! I like ginger parkin crumbs but digestives or hob nobs are great. Shortbread works well.


600g (net weight) peeled, diced apples

60g caster sugar


Mix the flour and butter together until it reaches a sandy, grain like consistency. Add the golden caster sugar, ginger parkin (or whatever you fancy) oats and mix well.

Add the apples to a dish and sprinkle with caster sugar. Cover the filling with the crumble topping. Bake in the oven at 180 degrees for 30-45minutes depending on the size of your dish. Remove from the oven and serve with custard.



More from Yorkshire Life

6 minutes ago

An artisan bread-making course and overnight stay at Cawthorne House plus dinner at The White Swan, Pickering

Read more
Yesterday, 00:00

A look inside the February 2020 issue of Yorkshire Life

Read more
Yesterday, 00:00

Dark nights and frosty mornings are here. We're all about big walks and cosy moments. Here's our pick of some desirable boltholes where you can go wandering from the doorstep.

Read more
Tue, 09:05

Richmondshire covers a part a large section of the most popular sections of the Yorkshire Dales, making it a perfect base for a walking break.

Read more
Mon, 00:00

art& promotes art and contemporary craft through workshops and informal shows.

Read more

Anna Makin-Jones has created a line of drinks made with English fruits and foraged botanicals

Read more
Thursday, January 16, 2020

Turn your thoughts to a shiny new property to make 2020 a milestone year

Read more
Wednesday, January 15, 2020

It's time to start snapping as we launch our photography competition in association with Yorebridge House.

Read more
Wednesday, January 15, 2020

A new year usually brings the will to live well and watch what you eat. Easy does it thanks to these Yorkshire 'good-for-you' businesses

Read more

Follow us on Twitter

Like us on Facebook

Subscribe or buy a mag today

subscription ad

Local Business Directory

Property Search

Most Read

Latest from the Yorkshire Life