Six of the best Christmas Puddings from Yorkshire

PUBLISHED: 00:00 15 December 2017

Christmas Pudding Getty Images/iStockphoto

Christmas Pudding Getty Images/iStockphoto


A look at the best Christmas puddings available in Yorkshire

I don’t know about you, but after downing my Christmas dinner — generally a button-popping plate of turkey with all the trimmings, roast spuds and Brussels sprouts — I like to look around for something else to eat, WRITES TONY GREENWAY.

It’s about this point that my eyes usually alight on a large, rich helping of Christmas pudding topped with enough cream or brandy butter to kill a small horse. Yum. Christmas just isn’t Christmas without it, is it? (Christmas pudding, I mean. Not gluttony.)

So what’s the difference between plum pudding and Christmas pudding? (Good question at the back, thank you.) Well, there’s no difference because they are, in fact, one and the same thing. The name ‘plum pudding’ only stuck because, in the pre-Victorian era, ‘plums’ was a catch-all term for any kind of dried fruit. And, seriously, don’t even get me started on figgy pudding. The fact is, it’s Christmas, and you’ll need a dessert. Handily, the following Yorkshire producers make fine Christmas/plum puds.

God bless them, every one.

Champagne Christmas pudding

Trust Bettys to take the idea of a Christmas pudding and ‘posh’ it up. Yes, you can buy one of their classic Christmas puds made with ale — and very nice they are too, based on an old Bettys family recipe (belonging to the mum of Lesley Wild, chair of the board). But how about trying this one on for size: a Champagne Christmas pudding made with cranberries, apricots, Moët Champagne and Marc de Champagne. It’s lighter than the ale versions, and — did we mention? — there’s champagne involved. You know what to do.

Gluten-free Christmas pudding

If you’re a professional Christmas pudding-maker, you’ve got to take the whole process seriously. How seriously? Well, put it like this: apparently, Burtree start making their Christmas puds in May, largely because it’s such a complex business. Burtree produce a dark Christmas pudding with rum, barley wine and stout but there’s also a Great Taste gold award-winning gluten-free version with brandy and cider that was named Best Gluten-free Christmas Pudding by The Guardian.

Victorian Christmas pudding

Jenkins & Hustwit was set up in 1990 by Ann Hustwit and Hilary Jenkins, two farmers’ wives and cookery teachers who decided to bake and sell the Yorkshire cakes they remembered fondly as children. The business was bought by Northallerton-based Sweet Moments in 2016 and produces various fantastic fruit and Christmas puddings. It’s tricky to choose but, if pressed, I’d plump for their boozy Victorian Christmas pud which is flavoured with Christmas spices including cinnamon, ginger, allspice, nutmeg and cloves.

Christmas pudding made with Ossett Brewery Treacle Stout

Carrots. Not, maybe, the first thing you think of when it comes to Christmas pudding but grated Yorkshire carrots are part of the charm of this one (after all, they work really well in carrot cake, don’t they?), plus local free-range eggs, milled flour from Yorkshire and Ossett Brewery’s Treacle Stout. Blacker Hall Farm Shop says this is made to a traditional Garthwaite family recipe and is ‘a true Wakefield Christmas treat’. You’ll get no arguments from me.

Traditional Christmas pudding

As supplied by the Harrogate Cake Company, the traditional Christmas pud you can pick up at Weetons (serving 6-8) is rich and luxurious, with ingredients that include brandy, black treacle and Christmas spices.

Plum pudding with Hennessy cognac

This is one of Lewis & Copper’s biggest sellers — and a Guild of Fine Food’s Gold Taste award-winner, to boot. It’s a rich pud made from a recipe that’s a century old, with oak-aged Hereford cider, claret and (natch) what Lewis & Cooper call ‘a generous lacing of Hennessy Cognac’. No wonder the Independent on Sunday once voted it ‘the number one foodie treat for Christmas’.

More from Christmas

Monday, December 16, 2019

Make it a Christmas worthy of the Great British Bake Off. Sandy Docherty was a contestant on GBBO and has some savvy and stylish recipes to make the festive season taste just fabulous.

Read more
Friday, December 13, 2019

Prue Leith is probably on more than a few dream dinner party guest lists. Surprisingly this year she won’t be using her culinary talents for the Christmas feast. We caught up with the Great British Bake Off presenter at Dean Clough in Halifax to find out her festive secrets.

Read more
Friday, December 6, 2019

Need inspiration for the festive feasting? We’ve scoured some of Yorkshire’s notable food producers and suppliers to discover dreamy treats for the Christmas table

Read more
Wednesday, December 4, 2019

From hearty hampers to gourmet gadgets, our clutch of festive goodies for the foodie in your life – made and found in Yorkshire.

Read more

Florist Louise Ford inspires with a step-by-guide to a wow-factor festive wreath for your home

Read more
Monday, December 2, 2019

Jo Naughton is queen of the sparkles when it comes to Christmas, heading up Harrogate-based Lights4fun. These are her tips for making your festivities merry and bright, inside and out

Read more
Thursday, November 28, 2019

York is lovely all year round, but it's particularly sparkly and atmospheric at Christmas. Tony Greenway delivers 12 glittering reasons for good cheer in his favourite festive city

Read more
Tuesday, November 26, 2019

A guide to some of the finest entertainment around Yorkshire this Christmas

Read more
Monday, November 4, 2019

With Christmas just around the corner, what better way to soak up the magic than at your local Christmas market?

Read more
Monday, November 4, 2019

If you’re looking to make your festive food shopping a little easier with sparing any quality, Booths have got you covered this Christmas.

Read more

Follow us on Twitter

Like us on Facebook

Subscribe or buy a mag today

subscription ad

Local Business Directory

Property Search

Comments have been disabled on this article.

Most Read

Latest from the Yorkshire Life